The idealisation of Dutch cycling in the British cycling press omits to mention that being a respected, mainstream means of transport incurs responsibilities as well as offering rights. Laws about lights, bells, bikes on trains, as well as compulsory paths, are rigorously policed. Taking a bike on a train requires a €6 ticket in addition to the cyclist’s fare – a significant cost for regular leisure riders.
None of this is unreasonable when the other side of the bargain is the combination of amenity and respect accorded to Dutch cyclists. But mutual respect takes a long time to build. A recent article (with an excellent video documentary) explains that it took the Netherlands about 25 years to get where it is today, from the depths of a child-killing car-centred policy in the 1970s.
Dutch perceptions of their system are as much about a culture of respect as they are about separate lanes. “Segregation,” Marc van Woudenberg of the blog Amsterdamize tells me, “is just one (important) part of bicycle policies in the Netherlands, complemented with integral spatial planning, traffic calming, bike facilities and effective traffic laws.” “Strict Liability,” explains GJ Baan of Dutch gear shop And Dutch, “is supported by the Dutch law … [it means] the driver’s insurance is deemed responsible when a collision occurs between a cyclist and a car.”
Frank de Jong, of dutchcitybike.com, points out that a system that respects cyclists promotes respectful cycling in return: “When I bike in Holland, I get the sense that the road was designed with bikes and cars in mind from the outset … I feel respected as a cyclist, and therefore I’m more likely to respect the traffic rules.”
Eric van der Horst, of the Cycling Dutchman blog, explains that motorists in the Netherlands are much more tightly regulated: “The hazards of speeding are fully recognised: speed limits are present everywhere, margins for offenders are tiny, paid parking is up to five times more expensive than in the UK.”
The London Cycling Campaign who are running a “go dutch” campaign for the upcoming mayoral elections have clarified their stance here and As Easy As Riding A Bike has also written a great response to the article which you can read here.